The Myth and the Cost of Recycling
Anybody read the book…"Eight Great Myth’s of Recycling" b y Daniel K. Benjamin? Well I have not. Not in it’s entirety anyways. I guess I just got too disgusted with it all. Basically the book points out eight (8) myths of recycling, contradicting the new "traditions" that motivate people to join the cause of recycling and return to their wasteful, traditional American lifestyles.
Here are the 8 myths: (including his contradicting statements that encourage non-earth conscience habits)
Our garbage will bury us.
Answer: Our landfill capacities are increasing. The US can expectedly handle the consumption and disposal for the next 100 years.
So what happens after that? Are we only planning for the next 100 years?
Our garbage will poison us.
Answer: EPA acknowledges that the risk to humans from modern landfills is virtually nonexistent.
Packaging is the problem.
Answer: Modern packaging saves breakage and waste, reducing disposal requirements; advances in packing have drastically decreased the volume of a given package.
YEAH RIGHT. I just honestly can not believe this is a true statement. After all, we are all consumers and looks can not be THAT deceiving. I would need real numbers and proof to support this statement.
We must achieve trash independence?
Answer: Trade in trash raises our wealth as a nation by 4 billion a year.
This would also be the case, if not more with recycling. Not to mention the non
monetary benefits!
We squander irreplaceable resources when we don’t recycle.
Answer: Price controls the use of resources. Resources are used but remain available; human ingenuity is the reason.
Recycling always protects the environment.
Answer: The US Office of Technology Assessment stated that recycling changes the nature of pollution, sometimes increasing it and sometimes decreasing it.
Well I’ll be darned! Yes we are in a trial and error state at this point. In every sense of the word. You think people were worried about global warming 150 years ago. NO. There was no need. Our daily lives didn’t cause such things to happen. So just as we are constantly adjusting and coming of age as a industrial, technological society, we must also as a recycling nation. That doesn’t mean that our attempts are not worthy or should be stopped.
Recycling Saves Resources.
Answer: Municipal recycling programs waste resources.
This may be true. Instead of relying solely on the municipal governments help, let’s all be proactive. We can not rely only on these forms of government as backbone of support. And besides, it’s not only recycling, but also parking tickets, etc…..I do not have to list!
Without forced recycling mandates, there wouldn’t be recycling.
Answer: When the price is right, the private sector recycles, a phenomenon that is "as old as trash itself".
Recycling must be profitable. Unfortunately, it’s the only way. But so long as so few people recycle, the more of a niche recycle stay, the less profitable it is…..more to follow…..
So, here is how Benjamin sees it, with a little of my twist on it. I think it is just complete and utter crap. If we cared as much as he did, the earth would be in trouble. It’s a prime example of why the over weight man stays fat. He can make 100 excuses. He is naturally big boned, or obesity runs in his family, or he’s tried every diet scam…blah blah. Bottom line, you have to eat right and exercise to maintain a healthy weight and American and the World at Large must reduce, reuse and recycle to keep this world a beautiful place to live.
I have a great article that I have just recently read about the recycling, the changes in recycling, and the economics of recycling in the city of New York that I would love to share. Let me compile the data and I will post shortly.
Also soon to come….exactly how much do those pesky plastic shopping bags cost?